Sarah, Plain and Tall

by Patricia MacLachlan

Sarah, Plain and Tall

Follow the links below to find free resources and book unit samples.

 

Book Information

Students should read Sarah, Plain and Tall by Patricia MacLachlan. The narrative of a family living on the American prairie in the late 19th century is told in this historical fiction book. After their mother passed away giving birth to Caleb, the father, Jacob, published an advertisement in the newspaper looking for a new wife and mother for his children, Anna and Caleb. The kids, who hardly remember or never know their mother, are lonely and curious about her. They hear back from Sarah Wheaton, a native of Maine who enjoys the sea and is single. She consents to pay them a month-long visit to see whether she can fit into their schedules.

The themes of family, love, loss, and fresh beginnings are all explored in this novel, which is an excellent approach to expose students to the history and culture of prairie life. The characters and settings are vividly described in the novel, which is presented in straightforward English. Beautiful drawings in the book also help to convey the tone and ambiance of the narrative.

Publication Date: April 1985


Reading Level: Lexile Measure 660L, Scholastic Guided Reading Level R


Interest Level: Grades 3-5


Major Awards: The has won several awards, including the 1986 Newbery Medal Winner, the Scott O’Dell Award for Historical Fiction, and the Golden Kite Award.


Number of Pages: 76 pages


Approximate Word Count: 34,160 words -- The average reader will spend 2 hours and 16 minutes reading Sarah, Plain and Tall at 250 words per minute. *


Audible Book Length: 1 hr and 1 min


Book Themes: Family, Home, Isolation, Fear, Sacrifice, Happiness, Choices, Contrasting Regions, Dreams


Genre: Family Drama, Historical Fiction


Setting: Midwest during the late 1800's


Important Quote: There is always something to miss, no matter where you are.


First Line: “Did Mama sing every day?” asked Caleb.


Point of View: First Person (Central - Anna Wheaton)


*Estimate from Reading Length

Links to Resources and Teaching Ideas

Sarah, Plain and Tall
Sarah, Plain and Tall

Sarah, Plain and Tall Bird Craft Project

While reading Sarah, Plain and Tall, students created these wonderful bird nests. Students made a bird nest from straw. First they glued a few dried flowers to the nest since Sarah loved them so. Next the birds were made by gluing pom-poms and feathers together. Finally a beak from Fun Foam and wiggly eyes were added.


Sarah, Plain and Tall
Sarah, Plain and Tall
Sarah, Plain and Tall
Sarah, Plain and Tall
Sarah, Plain and Tall
Sarah, Plain and Tall

Some fun activities for students to do while reading this book are:

  • Write letters to Sarah from Anna or Caleb’s perspective, asking her questions about her life in Maine or telling her about their life on the prairie. 

  • Draw pictures of Sarah’s shell collection or her cat Seal, using details from the book or their own imagination. 

  • Research more about the prairie life or Maine in the late 19th century, and create a poster or a brochure with facts and images. 

  • Compare and contrast Sarah’s life in Maine with Jacob’s life on the prairie, using a Venn diagram or a T-chart. 

  • Write a poem or a song inspired by Sarah’s love for the sea or Jacob’s love for the land. 

  • Make a list of words that describe Sarah, Anna, Caleb, or Jacob, and use them to create an acrostic poem with their names. 

  • Create a timeline of the events in the book, using dates and illustrations. 

  • Make a map of Sarah’s journey from Maine to the prairie, using landmarks and distances. 

  • Write an alternative ending for the book, imagining what would happen if Sarah decided to stay or leave.



  • I hope you find these activities useful and enjoyable for your students. I’m sure they will love reading Sarah, Plain and Tall as much as I did. Happy reading! 😊